Tuesday, September 2, 2014

EXPLANATIONS OF QURAN THROUGH AHADITH (Acutal Status of Hadith) BY GHULAM AHMED PARWEZ

EXPLANATIONS OF QURAN THROUGH AHADITH
The utmost need for Ahadith, we are given to understand, is because without them, we cannot grasp the correct interpretation of Quran. The argument given in favour of this statement is so powerful that every person is convinced. The argument is, can anyone’s explanation of any ayaat of Quran, be more correct than the explanation given by the Messenger Muhammad…. No doubt! We agree that no one’s explanation of Quran can go beyond that of the Messenger. The question we must ask ourselves: (the explanation of Quran that is present in our ahadith) is it the actual and true rendering of Messenger’s word? I am confident you will not be able to answer this question nor will you accept that it is not the explanation given by MuhammadPBUH, until and unless you do not read it with your own eyes, as to what is real hadith. For just this purpose we will copy from the most respected ahadith books, a few examples of the explanation of ayaat from Quran. After reading, you all can decide for yourself, whether we should attribute it to the Messenger Muhammad or not?
In the chapter of Ah’zaab in Quran, it is stated: 
(33:9)“O Believers! Do not become like those who became callous with Moses.”

MOSES AND ISRAELITES:
The different ways, in which the Israelites mistreated MosesPBUH, has been explained in the Quran in detail. If nothing else, the devotion and perpetual struggle of MosesPBUH, ought to have been enough reason for Israelites to be grateful to him all their lives. On the contrary, we observe, they blatantly told MosesPBUH. 
(7:129)
“We were in miserable condition before you came and we are miserable after your arrival.”
Torah maintains a detailed account. When the Israelites saw the Egyptians following them, it states them telling MosesPBUH.
            “Was there not enough place to bury us in Egypt, that you have brought us in this deserted place? What are you doing with us? Did we not mention, while in Egypt, to let go off us, So that we may serve the Egyptians? It would have been better for us to serve the Egyptians than die in wilderness.” (Exodus 14:10-12)
            In the plains of Sinai, The Israelites got healthy victuals, still they complained to MosesPBUH:
(2:61)
“Do we have to eat the same food every day!”
Torrah has it:
            “The whole coterie of Israelites in this wilderness fretted and fumed on MosesPBUH and AaronPBUH. They said, ‘we wish to God, we died in Egypt, when we were having our fill, out of pots of meat!” (Exodus 16:3-11)
When they were faced with a little shortage of water, they began to scream: “Why did you bring us out of Egypt, so that our children and animals may die of thirst.” (Exodus, 7:1-3)
While passing through a valley, these Israelites saw some people prostrating in front of a statue. They went berserk and demanded from MosesPBUH and made importunate pleas, to erect for them a similar statue. As is narrated in Quran: 
(7:128)
MosesPBUH had to climb mount Sinai and did not return for quite some time. Meanwhile, the Israelites made a model of a calf and began to worship it. (20:86).
Upon entering a village, they were asked to adopt certain measures; whereas we read, that on purpose they acted on the contrary. (2:58-59).
When MosesPBUH asked them to have faith in one God, they replied:
 (2:55)
“We will not listen to what you say, until we do not see God, with our own eyes!”
When they were asked to slaughter a cow, they made plenty of excuses, the details of which are in chapter Baq’ra of Quran. (Refer to 2:67). MosesPBUH told them, the sacred land has been destined for them, they only have to rise and take it. The Israelites replied, that until its inhabitants do not leave, they were not prepared to walk a single step in that direction. 
(5:24)
“You and your God can go and fight with those people. While we will wait here till then.”
This was the attitude of Israelites towards MosesPBUH, because of which he was impelled to tell them:
 (61:5)
“O my people! Why are you so cruel to me? You know very well. I am your Messenger sent from Allah.”
MosesPBUH was so exhausted by all this, he requested God almighty:
            “My God! I have no control over anything besides my brother and my own self. So you must decide between us and these arrogant people.”
Because of these happenings among Israelites, the Quran warns the Momineen, as not to follow in their footsteps: 
            “Do not behave like Israelites. The Messenger looses nothing by your merciless acts, on the contrary, that community becomes worthless which disregards the Messenger and annoys him.”
Please take into consideration the explanations of Quran and see for yourself, how the meanings of the above mentioned ayaat unfold. In comparison, let us observe how our ahadith explain the same ayaat. It has in Bokhari:
1.      “Abu HurairaR, while quoting the Messenger MuhammadPBUH narrates, the Messenger said, “Israelites had the custom of bathing naked in front of each other, while MosesPBUH took his baths in isolation. The Israelites gossiped among themselves, the reason MosesPBUH bathes in isolation is because he suffers from the disease of fituk. One day it so happened, MosesPBUH went to take a bath and put his garments on a nearby stone. The stone took away with his clothes and MosesPBUH ran after the stone saying
(                                          ) ‘O Stone! Give me my garments, O Stone! Give me my garments.’ In the meantime, Israelites were able to take a good look at MosesPBUH and said that he did not suffer from any disease. The stone stopped moving and MosesPBUH after taking his garments, began to beat the stone.” Abu HurairaR says—The stone, by God, still has six or seven marks from the beating of MosesPBUH.
(Bokhari, Vol. I, page 76).  (Sahih Bukhari: Kitab'ul Gusal (Bathing)
Please peruse the above commentary carefully, think for a moment, if this can possibly be the explanation given by the Messenger, of the ayaat from Quran?
2.      It has it in Trimidhi, Hazrat Ibne AbbasR while quoting MuhammadPBUH writes, “Archangel Gabriel told me, the pharaoh, when dying desired to believe in the God of MosesPBUH. And that, “I should have seen him, how he shoved mud of the ocean in pharaoh’s mouth, so that he may not announce his belief.”
First of all, let us see, if it is the duty of Gabriel to stuff mud into anybody’s mouth when the person desires to believe in God? Or someone who only wants to be blessed? We ought to know, it is written in Quran about angels: 
(16:50)
“The angels can do nothing on their own. They only obey the orders or commands of Allah.”
It can be inferred, the act of angel Gabriel (stuffing of ocean’s mud in the mouth of pharaoh) was ordained by God. We also know from Quran the pharaoh had embraced the faith of MosesPBUH. 
(10:90)
            Saideth pharaoh, “I believe there is no allah, except the Allah of Israelites and I am a Muslim.”

PHARAOH EMBRACES THE FAITH OF ALLAH:
According to the above-mentioned parable, God did not want that pharaoh should believe in him. In order to fulfill his desire. God appointed Gabriel to stuff the mouth of pharaoh with mud. As we read, inspite of it, pharaoh succeeded in declaring his faith in Allah. In other words (God forgive us), Allah’s plan was defeated and became a horse of another color.
Can you, even for a moment imagine, if the above explanation could belong to the Messenger?
3.      Quran defines Allah as: 
(57:3)
“God is beyond the limitations of time.”
These words are so clear and explicit, one does not have any problem in understanding them—
“He is the first and he is the last!” whereas we find in the collection of Trimidhi, A lengthy explanation of this ayaat by Abu HurairaR, the concise summary of which is:
“The Holy Messenger said that the distance between earth and sky is five hundred years of journey. And the distance between two skies is also the same. Now there are seven skies in all, the distance between the seventh sky and heaven is also five hundred years of journey. In the same way there is an earth beneath this earth, which is also five hundred years of journey. And there are seven earths. The distance between every two is also the same... After that the Messenger said,                  ‘He is the first and he is the last!’
We ask you to first read the Arabic ayaat and then peruse its commentary. Can it, by any means be claimed as the words of Messenger MuhammadPBUH?
In the same collection of Trimidhi, we read from Abu HurairaR,
            “The Messenger said, ‘the distance between one sky and the other is 71 or 72 or 73 years of journey. And there are seven skies in all. The distance between any two skies is also the same number of years. On top of the seventh sky is an ocean. That is also the same number of years deep. On the ocean are seven ibexes. The distance from their hoofs to their knees is also the same number of years. On the backs of these ibexes is heaven, that is also the same amount of years in height.”
In the first gospel of Abu HurairaR, we read in Trimidhi, the path from one sky to the other is five hundred years. In the same Trimidhi it is stated, the Messenger saying, the distance between two skies is 71 or 72 or 73 years. The glaring contradiction is very clearly obvious! 
The later story, that there are seven skies, on top of the seventh sky is an ocean; on the ocean are seven ibexes. And on the backs of these ibexes is the heaven. This is an explanation of the following ayaat from Quran, wherein is stated: 
(11:7)
In fact these words are very profound. The Quran says: 
(21:30)
“We have created every living creature from water.”
Meaning, life initiated from water and is dependent on water also. Life cannot sustain itself without water. The intrinsic resource of life is water. The later ayaat therefore means, that God has absolute control over water. In other words, God has complete authority and control on the primary source of life.
This was the truth that has been explained in Quran. And we also read, narrated in Trimidhi, its explanation attributed to MuhammadPBUH.
Now you can decide for your self, can it be claimed, in any way, as the explanation given by the Messenger? 
4.      In context with ‘the story of Adam,’ it is narrated in the chapter of Baq’ra in Quran: 
(2:31)
“And Man was taught the knowledge of all names.”
It is very obvious. The Arabic word ‘Adam’ symbolizes ‘mankind’ or ‘humankind.’ Humankind has been granted the capacity to grasp the knowledge of universe. Human being has also been given the freedom of choice, which is impossible to exercise without knowledge. Freedom to choose and knowledge go hand in hand.

EXPLANATION OF BOKHARI:
Now let us read what Bokhari’s collection of ahadith has to say about this. It is written:
            “Hazrat UnsR quotes the Messenger, who said, ‘On the day of judgement all Muslims will gather together and consult, as to whom they must appoint on this day, as their leader. They all will approach prophet Adam and say, he is their father. All angels were ordered to prostrate before him, he was taught the knowledge of all names. They all will then beseech him to ask God for his mercy, so they can be saved from the torture of hell. He shall show his helplessness and bemoan his first sin (when he ate the forbidden fruit); he will shy away from Allah and direct these people to Messenger NoahPBUH. As he was the first Messenger who came from Allah, on this earth, all men will then approach him. The Messenger will show his helplessness and remembering his first sin, shall guide these people to Messenger AbrahamPBUH. They all will then approach AbrahamPBUH, he shall say the same and guide these people to Messenger MosesPBUH. As Allah had personally talked with MosesPBUH and had given him his commandments. MosesPBUH will also be helpless on this day and will shy away after recalling his sin. He will then direct these people to JesusPBUH, as he is the word, the spirit and the Messenger of Allah. But he will also say the same and direct these people towards MuhammadPBUH, whose every sin has been forgiven. I shall then take all of them to AllahSWT to beseech his forgiveness and mercy. I shall request permission from AllahSWT to enter in his presence, which I shall be granted. Upon seeing AllahSWT I will go into prostration and say whatever AllahSWT puts into my head. At that time, a command (from AllahSWT) will come—O Muhammad! Lift your head and plead your case, so that your wish be granted.’ I will then lift my head and obey his command and beseech his mercy. At that moment one group will be pardoned (migrants, martyrs, pious and saintly personalities). I shall again approach AllahSWT and go into prostration and beseech his mercy. Again this time another group will be pardoned. Then the third and forth time I shall ask for mercy, until none shall remain, except those who have been forbidden by Quran and granted inferno forever.”  (Sahih Bukhari: Kitabul Tafsir)
In this conte that has been attributed towards MuhammadPBUH, there is not a single word mentioned about the knowledge of Adam. Secondly, we must notice that all prophets are repentant for their sins and do not have the courage to face God. Can this be the attitude of the Messengers of AllahSWT?
YOUR WIVES ARE LIKE YOUR FIELDS:
5.      It is narrated in chapter Baq’ra in Quran: 
(2:223)
“Your wives are similar to your fields. You can go to them as you go to your fields.”
Again it is very obvious, the purpose of going to your wives is, when you want to sow your seed or want off springs. For this, just as a farmer sows seeds in the proper seasons, so you must also conjoin with your wives at proper time periods. The explanation of this ayaat in Imam Bokhari’s Kitab ul Tafseer, is as follows:
Explanation:
Nafi reports that while reading Quran, Abdullah Ibne OmarR never spoke with anybody. One day I approached him when he was reading Quran. When he reached the words                     in chapter Baq’ra in Quran, he asked me if I knew as to when this ayaat was revealed. I replied in the negative. He then explained the glory of its revelation and resumed his recitation of Quran again. Abdul Samad has said that we receive a tradition from Ibne OmarR that says this ayaat was revealed, because some men were copulating with women. JabarR narrates the Jews, who said; whosoever copulates with his wife from backside shall have cross-eyed progeny. It is in those days this ayaat was revealed, proving the Jews of being wrong. Meaning, women can be engaged in any way one wants, in matters of copulation.” (Sahih Bukhari: Kitab'ul Tafsir)
This was taken from the collection of Imam Bokhari. Let us read, what Allama Badr ud Din Ainee and Hafiz Ibne Hijr Asqalani have to say on this topic.

Explanation of This Hadith:
Allama Ainee has first copied the hadith from Bokhari in the following manner: 
God’s order on the subject                                                           was explained to us by Isaae, who was told by Nadr Bin Shameel, who in turn was told by Aun to tell Nafay that, ‘until OmarR did not finish reading Quran he never spoke with anybody. One day I sat with him with a Quran, when he was reading chapter Baq’ra. He then asked me, if I knew at what period in time, this ayaat was revealed? When I replied in the negative, he then explained its context to me. The narrator then moves on and quotes Abdul Samad, that he was told by his father, who was told by Ayub (Sukhtiani), who was told by Nafay, who was told by Ibn OmarR that the explanation of                                           is that you can copulate in…. with your wife. This has also been explained by Muhammad Bin Yahya Ibn Saeed, from his father, who got it from Obaidullah, who got it from Nafay, who got it from Ibn OmarR.
After all this Allama Ainee further writes:
In the original book of Bokhari, there is a blank space. Then he goes on to indicate that it means the private part of your wife, but this is not correct.
This tradition is explained by Ibn Jareer, who is told by Abu Qulaba?, who has copied from Abdul Samad Bin Abdul Warris, who was told by his father, who uses the word                          (To copulate with your wife in Anus) in his explanation. (Umdah Tul Qari).

COPULATION IN ANUS:
This was the elucidation given by Allama Ainee. Now let us read what Hafiz Ibn Hajr Asqalani, has to say about this tradition:
“Ibnul Arabi has copied in Siraj ul Mureed, that Bokhari has copied this hadith in Tafseer and said                     after these words. A blank space has been left. This problem is very famous. Muhammad Bin Shaban has authored a complete book on this topic. And Muhammad Bin Shahnoon? Has proved it in his article, the hadith of Ibn OmarR is about copulating with woman in the Anus.
Mazri says, that priests are divided on this issue. Those who believe this tradition as being Halal. Have taken the above-mentioned ayaat for their support. Those who are against it say the concerned ayaat was revealed to defeat the statement of Jews. As has been quoted by Jabar.”
FAITH UL BARI:
As can be noticed, Hafiz Ibn Hajr proves the contradiction about sex with woman from the anul side. Some narrators believe in this tradition while others do not.
Now let us read what Allama Ainee further says on this topic. He writes:
NOTION OF IMAM MALIK:
“Ibnul Arabi has written in his book entitled, ‘Ahkaam ul Quran’ that majority agrees with this tradition. All statements on this subject have been collected by Ibn e Shaban in his book called, ‘Jamma ul Niswan’, in which he has attributed its justifications towards majority of disciples of the Messenger and Tabaeen. He has found justifications from many traditions that are attributed to Imam MalikR. But Malik’s followers deny this tradition, because of its evil and perverted habit. Imam Malik is also adamant that this tradition cannot be proved wrong, just because people do not believe in it.
Muhammad Bin Sa’ad who got it from Abu Sulaiman, who copied from Zajafi?, that he was present in the company of Imam Malik Bin UnsR. When he was questioned about sex with woman by Anus, he thumped his hand on his head, saying that he had just finished his bath, after getting over with it. In the same book Ibnul Qasim has copied that Imam Malik was unable to find any human, whom he could claim as his mentor, concerning this tradition. After that he quotes this ayaat read by Imam MalikR:
MalikR said, “What more can be said on this, as it is already very obvious.” He did not doubt in the least. As far as Imam Sha’afi’s religion was concerned, we heard Imam TahawiR saying, that he got it from Muhammad Ibnul Hukaam, who heard it from Imam Sha’afi saying that there is no hadith from Messenger that goes for or against this notion. It is therefore speculated, that it is allowed (Umda'tul Qari fi Sharah' Bukhari, Ainee: Hadith # 1634: bab # 601).
In other words, Imam MalikR was convinced of its being true and he himself practiced it also and Imam Sha’afi was speculating in favour of it. Haifz Ibn Hajr has also copied a polemical dialogue of Imam Sha’afi on this topic, with Imam Azam’s student named Imam MuhammadR.
He writes:
Imam Hakim has written about Imam Sha’afiR, in the manner of Ibn Hakum, of his famous polemical dialogues with Imam Muhammad Ibnul HassanR on this topic. Ibnul HassanR reasoned against Imam Sah’afi, saying that the word-cultivating field can only mean the vagina. Imam Sha’afi said that this means, besides vagina, all other places are forbidden. Ibnul Hassan accepted this rationale, that besides vagina all other places are not allowed. Imam Sha’afi further questioned, what if someone had sex between the ankles of his wife or between her elbows, would that be considered a fertile field? Imam MuhammadR said, those areas cannot be fertile field—Imam Sha’afi then asks the Imam, if he considered that type of sex as ‘haraam’? Imam MuhammadR said, “No.” Imam Sha’afi then asked his opponent, as to how can he rationalize about something, of which he himself is not convinced? Imam Hakum states that perhaps Imam Sha’afi may have believed in this tradition in his early years, as we notice, that he gave clarifications against it in his later years. (Fatih ul Bari fi Sharah Bukhari, Ibn Hajr: Hadith # 1634, Bab # 601).
You all have read the concerning ayaat of Quran. You have also gone through the (inhuman and degrading) explanations of this ayaat as they exist unfortunately in Bokhari’s collection. You have even glanced on the commentaries by different religious scholars, about this hadith. Now we leave it to you to decide if these could be considered the words coming from an honorable Messenger of AllahSWT? And if Quran could be, by any ways, understood from these kinds of ahadith?
 
DO NOT FORBID WHAT HAS BEEN MADE HALAL:
It is narrated in chapter Mu’aida of Quran: 
(5:87)
“O ye believers! Those things that have been made halal by Allah; do not waste them.”
It clearly means, not to restrict your self of self-imposed limitations imitations. Only those boundaries must remain, that has been demarcated by God only. Let us read, what is written in Kitab ul Tafseer of Bokhari on this. It says:
            “Abdullah Bin Masood states that they accompanied the Messenger in Jihad (Holy war) and we did not have women with us. As we could not tolerate this separation from women because of gusto and heat. They asked the Messenger’s permission if they could castrate themselves. The Messenger at first forbade them, then later on he permitted them to enter into temporary matrimony with the consent of a woman. So they could be saved from castration and also because no one will be able to cast an evil glance. After granting permission, the Messenger read the above mentioned ayaat of Quran.” (Sahih Bukhari: Kitab'ul Tafsir)
MUTA:
By this above tradition we observe, the convention of Muta because permissible. In Kitab ul Nikha of Bokhari we read:
            “Salma Bin Akku says, they were on a Holy war path accompanying the Messenger (on the war of Hunain). Messenger, one day, came to them and said that Muta was permitted. They could do Muta.” (Translation, Vol.III, page 61)  (Sahih Muslim: Kitab'ul Nikah)
Another tradition has it:
            “Salma Bin Akku quotes the Messenger saying, “Whichever man and woman feels comfortable with each other can indulge in liberties for three nights. They are free to increase or decrease their time limit.” (ibid)  (Sahih Bukhari: Kitab'ul Nikah)
DETAILS OF MUTA:
Let us read more on this, as narrated in Sahih Muslim:
            A tradition comes from Subra Jehny?, when his holiness gave permission to do Muta. “Me and another person went to a woman in Bani Amir together. When we disclosed our desire, she wanted to know her compensation. We both said that we would give our shawls. My partner’s shawl was better than mine, But I looked younger than him. When the woman looked at our shawls, she was inclined towards him, and when she looked at our bodies, she came towards me. Finally she decided that me and my shawl would be good enough for her. And so I stayed with her for three days.” (Sahih Muslim: Kitab'ul Nikah)
Again, you must decide, if these stories can ever come from the honorable lips of Messenger MuhammadPBUH.
6.      In chapter Ma’aida of Quran, it is written, on the day of judgment, AllahSWT shall ask Messenger JesusPBUH, if he said to his people to worship him and his mother? JesusPBUH will reply, “Heaven forbid! How can I dare say such a thing. I only advised and urged the people to believe in one God.
 (5:117)
“As long as I was among them, I supervised their activities (so they may not take wrong paths). But when I left them, then the responsibility fell upon you. Whatever they did in my absence, I cannot be held responsible for it.”
Companions of the Messenger became Murted:
Every word of it is so obvious and clear, but the tradition being brought forward from Bokhari’s collection cannot be overlooked also:
Ibne AbbasR has it that the Messenger delivered a sermon, “O people! You all will be risen towards Allah naked feet, naked body and without circumcision.” Messenger then recited the following ayaat:
 (2:104)
“We shall bring you up in the same condition, on doomsday, in which you were born. This is our promise, and it is up to us to complete this task.”
Messenger then said, “Abraham will be the first one to be covered with clothes. Be warned few people from my Ummat shall be brought forth and escorted by angels towards hell. At that moment I shall say to Allah that they are my companions. And a voice will boom (from Allah), telling that I do not know, what they did after I left them. At that moment I shall also repeat the words of JesusPBUH.
The voice from Allah will boom again, saying that these people became infidels, soon after you separated from them.” (Sahih Bukhari: Kitab'ul Tafsir)
This is being written about those (God forgive us) disciples, who fought wars and gave every once of their blood for the sake of Allah. It cannot even be imagined, the above story can ever be the words of the Messenger!
7.      It has it in the chapter of Joseph in Quran, when the reigning king heard the interpretation of his dream by JosephPBUH, he was very enthralled by his knowledge. And so he sent for JosephPBUH.
JOSEPH’S CHARACTER:
First of all, who does not want to get out of jail cells? All the more reason, when the captive individual happens to be innocent and the king desires to reward him/her. Under normal circumstances anybody would fall for such a call. But the characters of prophets and Messengers are above and beyond all these small temptations. Joseph’s reply to the king’s courier was, that he had no desire to come out of the cell in this manner. Joseph told the courier to go back to the king and ask, if the case in which he was involved, has been investigated into and finalized. If the king, only after re-investigation, concludes that he was innocent, only in that case will he be eager to come out of jail: 
(12:50)
This was the demonstration of the high and mighty character of prophets. But what we read in the explanation of Bokhari is:
Looking at the time period of JosephPBUH in jail, the Messenger said, “If I was in his place, I would have opted to come out of the cell!” (Sahih Bukhari: Book of Prophets)
It is brazenly obvious that this tradition is a blatant outcry of some Jew, who only wanted to elevate the character of their prophet (JosephPBUH) above and beyond that of (God forgive us) MuhammadPBUH. And this tradition is also attributed to the Messenger.
Numerous amount of these kind of ahadith can be provided from Saha Sitta (the six most honored ahadith collections). But we shall suffice with only the above mentioned few examples, so that you all may surmise as to what is written in our ahadith books. At the same time our archaic believers are adamant, that we must believe these books as the most authentic and true words of the Messenger.
We will conclude this discussion with a tradition from the famous Trimidhi. After examing this heart rending tradition, just think, if we can lift our eyes up with dignity and honour. It has it in the chapter of Hijr: 
(15:24-25)
“We know those who came before and those who will come after you. Your god will gather them together. He is wise, He is knowledge.”
It is absolutely clear, that God will bring together all those people who have gone by and those that belong to future. Another ayaat having a similar meaning is narrated: 
(56:48-51)
“Say! Those that came before and those who came after, on the appointed day, shall be together.”
Now let us read the commentary of the above ayaat of chapter Hijr:
It has it in Trimidhi, that Ibne AbbasR narrates,
“In the Mosque, there came a fair belle every day to pray after the Messenger. Among the disciples, some of them moved behind her, so as not to be distracted. While others moved ahead, and when bent forward in prayers, took a peek at her through their armpits. Because of this, AllahSWT brought down this revelation, that he was aware of those ahead and those who were behind.”
We do not think, any kind of comments are necessary on this. Traditions of this sort, speak out for themselves, that these are nothing but fabricated lies. These traditions have been concocted by conspirators of Islam and attributed to MuhammadPBUH. Unfortunately, our clergymen are obstinate, as not only we have to believe in these myths, we also must believe, these were revelations brought by archangel Gabriel upon MuhammadPBUH.
These clergymen are in the strong notion that:
           “Gabriel came with Quran and Sunnah both. And taught Messenger the Sunnah just like the Quran.” (Quoted from Jamaat-e-Islami ka Nazariya-e-Hadith. Page 60 from Sheikh-ul-Hadith, Maulana Muhammad Ismail.)
            Meaning these traditions were God sent to Messenger through archangel Gabriel.

---------------------------------------
[1][This ayaat is usually translated that your women are your fields. You can go to them however way you please. Whereas the correct translation is that your women are your fields, you can go to them whenever you place] (Bokhari, Kitab ul Tafseer, page 649, Mujtabaee).

Monday, September 1, 2014

FORMALISM IN HADITH (The Actual Status of Hadith) by Ghulam Ahmed Parwez

FORMALISM IN HADITH
The Messenger of Allah, had repeatedly asserted and stressed, “Whosoever, on purpose (some say the words, ‘on purpose’, are a later addition in this tradition. Tolu-e-Islam) falsifies my statements, is inviting hellfire for himself.” This tradition has been narrated by ever so many a disciple that because of it some hadith authorities have declared it Muta’water. Inspite of this warning from the Messenger, we descry there existed some who distorted and falsified hadith in the lifetime of the Messenger. Mulla Ali Qari, we find in ‘Mau’zoo’at e Kabeer’ has written:
“In a distance of two miles from Medina, someone by the name of Hyye Bani Lace, sent a matrimonial message to a woman. Mentors of the woman accepted this wedding invitation. This person wore a hullah (garment in Islamic folklore worn in paradise) similar to that of the Messenger, and went there, claiming the Messenger had bestowed the hullah to him, and he also had granted him the authority to say whatever he may please, about their women. On learning that MuhammadPBUH the Messenger had given the folks of the locality, these orders, they bowed their heads in submission. They gave this person a place to stay, and in the meantime, sent two of their men to verify, on what this man claimed himself to be. When the Messenger came to know about it, he was very displeased and extremely annoyed. He ordered the fellow to be executed and then incinerated. Upon reaching there, the Messenger’s soldiers found the guy had already died of snake bite and so they burnt his body and came back.”
Sheikh Zahir Jazai’ri writes in his book ‘Tau’jeeh ul Nzarali ul Asul ul Asar,’ on page 246:
“The Messenger was falsified in his very lifetime, and that there were hypocrites and heretics present in the period of his confreres.”
DAYS OF DISCIPLES:
The Messenger had categorically stated: 
“Do not have me dictate anything save the Quran, whosoever has written anything other than the Quran, must erase it.”
The rationale behind this, given by the scholars of religion was, the Messenger said these words, so the Quran may not become a conglomerate. But this cannot be true, as the Messenger could also have said, to write the ahadith and Quran separately. The actual purpose of his having said thus, was because people may not involve themselves in traditions. As we know, when traditions begin to prevail, there remains no discrimination between true or false.
We observe, during the reign of the first Caliph Hazrat Abu Bakr SiddiqR, there began a controversy among people, over the traditions. When it came in the knowledge of Caliph, he said after making them assemble,
“Today you all contradict the traditions, there will come a time when you all will contradict each other even more fanatically. Therefore, do not quote the Messenger.” (refer to Tz’kara tul Hif’aaz by Imam Zuhby)
Hazrat Abu BakrR also had a personal collection of 500 ahadith in Hazrat AishaR’s possession. Thinking later, he may have inadvertently confirmed a false statement of the Messenger, he got the collection back from her and made a bonfire of it. (Ibid)
We cannot say for sure, if his whole collection was based on hearsay; as he was Messenger’s personal companion, and so had the privilege of listening to him personally. There could therefore be no doubt in his personal ahadith. Just because he had observed, the arguments over traditions with his own eyes, in his capacity as a Caliph, having forbidden everybody from writing the traditions, he did not assume it safe to leave behind any collection of traditions.
We also read in Sahih Bokhari from Abu HurairaR, that Amru bin Aas also had a collection of sayings of Messenger in his possession. We have no knowledge of it today with us, whether it vanished in thin air or was it also incinerated, like Hazrat Abu BakrR did. All these precautions were taken due to the menace of hypocrites. What they explained, was absolutely different from what they had heard. In the period of the disciples, after the passing away of Messenger, there were also agnostics along with hypocrites in existence. It was also because of this reason, Abu BakrR laid a prohibition on traditions. While those traditions, which he listened from the disciples, he demanded guarantors or witnesses. Later Caliph Hazrat OmarR was more strict; he banned anyone from involving themselves in traditions. In spite of these preventive measures and precautions, these traditions could not be ceased from spreading. We find that where on the one hand, we get authentic explanations, we also on the other hand get those traditions that have been fabricated. Thus, we read in Sahih Muslim, when Basheer bin Ka’ab began to explain ahadith in front of Hazrat Ibne AbbasR, he paid no attention to him. Basheer asked the reason for his not paying him any attention. Hazrat AbbasR replied, there was a time when they were all ears at the mention of Muhammad’s name. Ever since people began to fabricate tales and stories, they have given up on Hadith.
This was also the reason, the respected disciples had given up narrating ahadith. Ibne abi Laila asked Zaid bin Arqa’an to narrate any hadith he was in knowledge of. Zaid replied that he had grown old and had forgotten. Abdullah requested his father Hazrat Zubair R, to tell him of any saying of the Messenger that he knew. He also gave the same reply. Sa’ib bin Yazid says that he journeyed from Medina to Mecca with Hazrat Sa’ad bin Malik, he did not hear a single tradition from him. Imam Saabi says that he lived for one year with Hazrat Omar R. In that period he never heard any hadith from his lips.

POST DISCIPLES ERA:
After the era of disciples, we notice a huge increase in the number of hadith narrators as well as fabricators. Allama Ibn Joz’ee states the following causes for the indiscriminate spread of hadith:
1.                  Some people because of their carelessness distorted the version.
2.                  Some scholars lost their memory with age; after taxing their minds, they spoke whatever they could remember.
3.                  Many trustworthy narrators, because of old age mental deficiency, spoke of incorrect traditions.
4.                  Among them were also some, who inadvertently told incorrect traditions. When their mistakes were brought to their knowledge, these people considered it beyond their dignity to do anything about these wrong traditions.
5.                  The Aj’mees (Those who became Muslims, though inwardly they were against Islam. Their number was not any less during the Abbasid period) made numerous counterfeit and fake ahadith, that proved destructive to the principles of Islam. In their ostensible eulogy, they were proving the Shar’iah incorrect, deleting the ayaat of Quran and portraying the character of MuhammadPBUH as weak.
6.                  Religious bifurcations commenced and new sects came into existence. Like Shi’ites, Sunnis, Qadris, Jehemy, Muz’jiya, Mo’tzilla et all. Each one of these made up their own hadith, that praised their own sect and was against all others.
7.                  Many good people also made ahadith with a good and a holy morale in it.
8.                  Many thought it was granted to attribute wise adages to the Messenger and then have them attested as traditions. It is written in Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at that one hadithist gave up this profession in his old age and cautioned others to scrutinize ahadith before accepting them, as people were in the habit of including everything, that which suited their temperament, in Deen.
9.                  The favorites of later Caliphs and Ameers, made traditions and used them as means of getting closer to top officials.
10.              Professional orators and storytellers, attributed various stories to Messenger and made capitol on it.
These were the ten causes because of which false and fabricated ahadith spread among the Muslims. Above and beyond all these, the damage caused by political groups, who wanted to win the hearts of voters, by using Islam was also devastating. They made and concocted ahadith and spread it from east to west. And much more damage came from those who fabricated ahadith, to emboss their knowledge and tried to force respect, from the hearts of their people.
Sheikh Muhammad Tahir Gujrati writes in his book ‘Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at,’ a narrator gave up ahadith writing in his later years of life. He also now cautioned others from accepting any hadith or parable. As mentioned before, they made hadith on every subject, that was in accord with their wishes and they could lay their hands on. In other words, making hadith meant to attribute the story or gospel to MuhammadPBUH.
There were others who falsified ahadith in broad daylight. Some made hadith to gain fame, and some were so naive, they actually thought, to fabricate hadith was an act of faith and jihad. We read in Biyazwi’s explanations and other books, Noah bin abi Maryam eulogized and made ahadith on every verse of the Quran. When the authorities of those times on hadith, demanded verification of those gospels, he admitted and said that he had fabricated ahadith to attract and persuade people towards Quran. The storytellers and orators were more daring and much more blunt. (After this the author, late Allama Jirajpuri, has copied those ahadith that were told by these orators and storytellers. Since these have been mentioned in the earlier chapter, we are therefore deleting the text here.)

SUBJECTS OF AHADITH:
The volume of narrators became so huge, that many a times their translations occupied twelve volumes. We can very well imagine the diversity of subjects that were covered by these narrators, in all these ahadith. Sheikh Muhammad Tahir Gujrati writes in Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at, that Jonbari, Ibne Akkasha and Muhammad bin Tameem Farabi together had made ten thousand ahadith. He writes about Ibne abi ul Au’jaa, when they went to execute him, he admitted of having fabricated four thousand ahadith. In those ahadith he gave religious sanctions on prohibited things and abjured those that were allowed or hallal.
Leaving aside the question of traditions, we find at times, these pseudo-narrators, that are from beginning to the end, full of totally fabricated ahadith, have authored complete books. On page #8 in Tz’kara tul Hifaaz it states:
            “In Hadith books we come across some, that contain totally fabricated ahadith. Among these books is one by Al Qadha’ee, and another is called Arba’uun au Da’aniya. We do not find a single correct hadith in any of them. In another book called Wasaya Ali, apart from its first hadith all the rest are concocted and homemade. The musnid of Ans Basri is a collection of three hundred ahadith that are all false and fabricated. Ibne Addi writes about Musa bin Jaffer, who wrote a book about his ancestors that was brought in the knowledge of Hazrat AliR. It was a collection of one thousand ahadith. After going through the whole collection, Dar Katni declared the book as concocted, totally false and disgraceful. He has attributed to Hazrat AliR, traditions, on coitus and methods of copulation in the book.”
Wilmy states about Abul Fazal Jaffer bin Muhammad Hussain’s book called ‘Al Uroos’, as irrelevant and blasphemous. And Imam Zuhby is of the opinion, the collection of traditions of Ibne As’haaq bin Ibraham, do not deserve any attention.

FALSE BOOKS ON HADITH:
When verifications began on ahadith, the scholars with critical acumen, sifted through the traditions. They compiled a collection of weak ahadith. The famous collections among these are called:
·        Kt’aab ul Abat’eel, by Abu Abdullah al Hussain Humadani, (died 546 hijra).
·        Al Mau’zoo’at ul Kibra, in four volumes, by Abul Frig Abdul Hama’an Jozee, (died 597 hijra).
·        Fil Ahadith ul Mau’zooah and                          , by Jalal uddin Sayyuti.
·        Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at, by Sheikh M. Tahir, famous hadithist from Gujrat, Pakpattan, Pakistan, (died 986 hijra).
·        Risalat’aan fil Mau’zoo’at, by Razi uddin Sa’naee, (died 652 hijra).
·        Al Fawa’yat al Majmu’ah, by Sheikh Abu Allah Muhammad Shami (died 942 hijra).
·        Fil Ahadith ul Mau’zoo’ah, by Imam Shaukani Yemeni, (died 1255 hijra).
·        Kt’aab ul Mughani, by Hafiz Zia uddin Moosali (died 623 hijra).
·        Al Mau’zoo’at tul Sariyya, by Omar bin Badar.
·        Al Kashif ul Ilahi, by Muhammad Sandarussi, (died 1177 hijra).
·        Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at, by Mulla Ali Qari (died 1014 hijra).
·        Al Lulu al Mar’sooah, by Muhammad bin Khalil Qauqchi, (died 1305 hijra).
Hadith suffered so much in the hands of these narrators, that it cannot even be imagined. The ahadith that were attributed to MuhammadPBUH, ninety-nine percent belonged to his life in Medina that spans a length of ten years. The army of fake hadith makers had grown very large, they had nothing else to do but fabricate ahadith day in and day out. Most of these fabricators had adopted hadith making as their profession.
Thousands of these fake hadith makers made innumerable ahadith and spread them across continents. In this cyclone of fabrications and concoctions, we did have a few authentic ahadith, but it became impossible for the critics, or rather we can say, it was like looking for a needle in a haystack, to bring these genuine pearls in the limelight.

CRITIQUE ON HADITH:
When the scholars on hadith began to sift the conglomerate of right and wrong, they had two things on their minds. The first thing was the content of hadith and secondly, it was its preamble. To recognize false ahadith, these scholars formulated the following principles:
1.      That the hadith has false historical dates.
2.      Any traditions attributed to Rafzis (dissenters) against the Messengers companions, and Kharijites (those who drifted away from the mainstream) against the Ahle-bait (family members of the Messenger.)
3.      That many narrators are explaining the circumstances of this hadith, but in reality the tradition goes only by one name.
4.      That it goes against the Quran.
5.      That it is against reason or common sense.
6.      That it promises huge rewards for minor deeds and huge punishments for negligible sins.
7.      That it is against circumstantial evidence.
Very few fake ahadith could be encircled or sifted by applying these later principles. As those fabricators who made minor or small ahadith, always made sure, all aspects were taken care of, that could lead others to believe in its fake appearance. Just as we observe in our own times, that in spite of powerful arguments by attorneys, false witnesses get away with their fake statements. Sometimes these false witnesses have a more telling effect as compared to genuine witnesses. Therefore, these above mentioned principles, for weeding out fake ahadith have proved futile. The religious critics tried to work out other ways of sifting right from wrong ahadith, but nothing seemed to produce any concrete results. Yahya bin Saeed al Kattaan, who is considered as the father of critical acumen or arguments, is of the opinion, there can be no bigger liars than the well wishers of ahadith. Imam Muslim says, mistakes can be made by even the most experienced hadithist.
Ayub Sukhtian’ee had formed an excellent opinion about his neighbour, on his knowledge, purity and worship habits. At the same time, he was not prepared to believe in his neighbour’s verdict, even on a thing as small as a date palm tree (quoted from Tou’gee ul Nazr, page 25). Hence the criterion for judging hadith was its sheer popularity or fame. Meaning, only those ahadith were considered authentic, that had been narrated by recognized or popular hadithists.
In actuality, ahadith entered in book form, on a mandate from Omar bin Abdul Aziz, in the beginning of second century hijra. Although, we do find hadith criticism in that period, but actual criticism, to determine fake ahadith, began in third century hijra. The critics of this later period were not without mistakes. It has it in Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at that: 
“All this material can only be comprehended by hadithists by glancing over the deeds or credentials; otherwise nothing comes close to conviction. As to what the critics judge as accurate, may perhaps be false in its spirit and what they determine as false, could turn out to be absolutely true.”
The critical religious scholars are not prepared to consider even the most authentic of ahadith with conviction, they take them only as speculations. The way these critics have categorized ahadith, for example as solid, true, popular or weak, fake, etc., etc., it seems they can not decide with any finality. As hadith can only belong to two categories—it can either be true or it can be false!
However, it seems the critiques that have come down to us on hadith, still need to be re-evaluated. A very intensive, hard line, hadithist, Allama ibne Jo’zee in his book entitled, Al Mau’zoo’at ul Kubra, has negated most of ahadith of Bokhari, Muslim and Snun Ara’biah. Hafiz Ibne Hajr, who is very lenient, or we can say, has a soft corner in his heart for ahadith, is also doubtful on Ibne Jo’zee. He writes that Jo’zee has so many fake ahadith in his four volumes that a separate book on it could easily be compiled.

GRAVE CONSEQUENCES:
In spite of the fact, hadith scholars did make an earnest attempt on saving the Muslim ummah from fake ahadith, it appears to have done little good. The influence of fictitious ahadith had such a strong impact on the minds and was so deep rooted that even till today, these fake ahadith are taken as a treasure of Deen of Islam. In the history of Hadith, we cannot find a single book that is written without counterfeit gospels, sayings and traditions. Some books, if not completely, will mostly contain fictitious ahadith. For example:
a.                   Sal’aat ul Ts’beeh—does not contain a single authentic hadith.
b.                  Sal’aat ul Ha’jaat—does not contain a single authentic hadith.
c.                   Sal;’aat ul Fi’heeh—does not contain a single authentic hadith.
It is stated in Tz’kara tul Mau’zoo’at, that in some Sufi books, for example Quwat ul Kaloob, by Abu Talib and in the explanatory books of Salb’ee, it has been incorrectly mentioned, that ‘night of values’ (Shub e Kadr), falls in the middle of the month of Sha’baan. People began to read Sal’aat ul Fi’heeh in this night of the year. They divided themselves in groups of ten and began reciting hundred of verses each, on this night. This Night of Values (or Shub e Bar’aat) was given more importance, than the annual Eed day, which happens to fall after ramadaan, every year. This night was now being celebrated as an annual fair, in which they practiced and spoke so much blasphyemy, that saints took to going into wilderness fearing the wrath of Allah may not happen. It was first of all practiced in 448 hijra in Bait ul Muqdass. This practice then covered the whole of Egypt and Syria. This wrong practice was impeded by righteous scholars, nevertheless, we do find it being practiced till the eight century hijra. Sheikh Ali bin Ibraham wrote in one of his periodicals, the practice of bringing lights or lighting up on Shub e Bar’aat was initiated by Bramka, a convert into Islam. He found an alterative to appeasing his need of his former practice of fire worship. This practice later on gradually acquired the form of fire works, that eventually spread from east to west. The list of famous fake ahadith books, of Sufis is as following:
I.                    Zia’rat Kubr e Nabi—not even one hadith is correct in it.
II.                 Fooza’yat e A’ema Ar’biah—not even one hadith is correct in it.
III.               Fooza’yat e Arab au Zu’baan e Arabi—“ditto”.
IV.              Mau’zoo’at e Ajam au Zu’baan e Ajami—“ditto”.
V.                 Fooza’yat e Abdul e Autaar e Kutb au Ghaus—“ditto”.
            We can hardly find any authentic hadith, in the scholars of Mut’kalafeen also. For example:
I.                    Fooza’yal e Sahabaa—Mostly fake ahadith.
II.                 Mna’kub e Ahil’e Bait—Mostly fake ahadith.
III.               Hud’yah aur Toofah ki Fazi’lat—Mostly fake ahadith.
IV.              Nikah ki Fazi’lat aur Aurtoon ki Mu’daah—Mostly fake ahadith.
V.                 Fooza’yat e Dr’ood—Mostly fake ahadith.
VI.              Mu’daah e Nabi (Salalah alay’heeh Ws’salam) —Mostly fake ahadith.
Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal writes, three kinds of books have no value at all. Those are Mughazi, Mulla’him and Tuf’seer. Although scholars have raised objection to this statement of Hanbal, nonetheless, his statement is not dependent on any objection. Any reader shall see, that if a handful of ahadith do prove to be correct, we can easily count them as exceptions. All ahadith about the separation of ummah are weak in essence. For example, we read the Jews and An’sars will be divided into 72 sects. The Messenger says, his ummah shall be divided into 73 sects, only one among them will enter the gates of Heaven. The discrepancy of this hadith is very obvious, when seen in context with the historical period. That is, the 73 sects of Muslims were declared by the religious scholars already in the fourth and fifth centuries hijra. After that numerous sects came into existence and more sects are being created.

FAKE DISCIPLES:
Although hadith scholars and historians together are in complete accord over the fact, the last remaining disciple of MuhammadPBUH was Hazrat Abul Fiel Amir bin Da’ilah. He passed away in 102 hijra in Mecca. But what we observe from the writings of fabricators is very different. They introduced new disciples, long after the first century.
These disciples were:
I.                    Jabeer bin Harab—Hafiz Ibn Hajr writes about this fake disciple, that he participated in the Holy War of Khun’daq. Ameer Abdul Kareem bin N’sar says that he saw him with his own eyes in 573 hijra with Imam Nasir.
II.                 Abu Abdulah bin Muhammad Saqli—He lived in fifth century hijra. He was famous for having shook hands with Messenger MuhammadPBUH. People considered it sacred to shake hands with him.
III.               Kais bin Tameem—He had a scar on his forehead. It was said about him, Hazrat Ali’s mule kicked him. He lived in Gheelon. We find traditions written about him in the beginning of sixth century hijra (about 517 hijra)
IV.              Rattan Baba Hindi—He died in 632 hijra. It is said about him that he participated in Hazrat Fatimah’s marriage. He lived in India.
            They created these fake disciples of MuhammadPBUH and narrated numerous ahadith through them. Some considered these ahadith as roots and quoted them as deeds of authority. The mental state of these religious scholars was so frozen and stagnant, that when authorities on ahadith denied these stories, people became annoyed with them. For example, when Imam Zuh’bee declared the traditions of Baba Rattan as weak or fake, Allama Mujad Uddin Kamoos was annoyed and upset. By the same token, Allama Safdi opposed Hafiz ibn Hajr, when the latter contested these stories.